Sophia and the Mess: What a Messy Room Can Teach Us About Parenting

This morning, I walked into Sophia’s room and felt my disappointment leap to the surface. She’d had a sleepover Friday night. It was now Monday. Her overnight bag was still full. Her school bag was half-unzipped, spilling out wrappers, scraps, and a sock. The desk—one of those that opens from the top—was overflowing with papers, hairbands, crayons, and some other unidentifiable bits that might’ve once been food. Or art. Or both.

I pointed out the overnight bag—just a casual observation—and I watched her whole body shift. Her back stiffened, like a cat suddenly on alert. Her voice changed too, thinner, tight with a kind of pre-cry that didn’t surface but hovered underneath.
“I’ll do it. Mommy, don’t. Mommy, don’t.”

And there it was: that painful, familiar moment as a parent when you’re trying to help, but your help starts to feel like pressure. You want to offer support, but it’s experienced as control. You want to guide, but it’s received as critique.

She wasn’t being defiant. She was protecting something inside herself.

She also said: “I care about my plants. My succulents. I care about my snails. But I don’t care about that stuff. You guys care. Not me.”

And I believe her.

But I also wonder if there’s something she’s not fully saying. Something she hasn’t fully felt.

Because she’s someone who takes care of everyone. She’s so tuned in. With friends, with teachers, even at home—she anticipates needs, helps, checks in. She mediates when her little group of four girls gets tangled in conflict—and somehow ends up being the one the teacher turns to for resolution.

She’s ten.
Because that’s how she’s wired.

She gives hard.
And when you give that hard, criticism doesn’t land as information—it lands as failure.
She holds herself to impossible standards and then dissolves when others don’t treat her with the same generosity.

That may be true.
But it’s also not the whole story.

Another part of me fears the opposite.
That this room, this chaos, isn’t freedom.
That she doesn’t care for her space not because she’s free—but because she’s empty. Because she’s used herself up elsewhere and doesn’t have anything left for herself.

That the mess isn’t rebellion.
It’s depletion.

And if she never learns to care for her own space, her own calm, her own systems, she might end up in a cycle of depletion she can’t get out of.

That’s the complexity of parenting—the not knowing.
It’s rarely either/or.
It’s both, layered, contradictory.

And there’s another layer for me, too. The fear that her chaos will become entrenched. That it won’t stay cute and quirky and childlike.

She’s different from me.
She’s more like Niels.
A little bit of a hoarder. Sprawling. Her drawers are like collage boxes—socks and tape and rocks and handwritten notes folded into tiny squares. It’s wild. And for someone like me, it’s unnerving.

But it’s not just the mess.

It’s the fear that this disorganization—if left unchecked—will become a pattern.
One that gets in her way later.
That it’ll harden into adulthood.
That the mess could swallow her one day, the way it sometimes swallows adults who never learned to build systems that support them.
How the mental clutter mirrors the physical.
And how hard it is to untangle once it sets in.

There’s a theory I have, something I call the Empty Sink Rule.
When the sink is empty, people tend to keep it clean. There’s order, and it maintains itself.
But once a single plate gets left behind, the whole system slips.
One bowl turns into three, then seven, then an entire countertop of surrender.
Order invites care.
Disorder invites more of itself.
And I worry that her room is becoming the sink with one dirty plate left too long.

But what do you do when your natural go-to—to guide, to teach, to scaffold—ends up pushing your child away?

Even when I try to help her gently, I hit resistance.
Not because she’s trying to be difficult.
But because she’s trying to hold onto herself.
And because my help—however well-intentioned—feels like pressure.

You can’t force your way in.
You also can’t give up and say, “Fine, do whatever.”
Neither pole is parenting.

So I’m learning to find the middle.
To approach gently, not with critique but with curiosity.

Because yes, there are real skills here—routines, containers, tiny resets that build resilience.
But they only land if they’re rooted in dignity, not shame.
In invitation, not command.

This is the tension we live in as parents.

To respect who our children are while still believing in what they don’t yet know.
To step in without overwhelming.
To step back without abandoning.
To hold space for their tenderness, even when it comes out sideways.

And maybe that’s the work:
Not to make them into us, but to stand beside them as they become themselves.
Even if that means watching them wade through their own mess until they find the desire to sort it.
Even if that means keeping the rest of the sink empty—just in case one day, they decide to do the same.

Are you interested in working on your personal development? Are you looking for a life coach or a life consultant? Are you feeling stagnant? Do you want to jumpstart change?

 My transformational approach is a process where awareness, alignment, and action work together as catalysts to create momentum for change. 

*Awareness is knowing what you genuinely want and need.

*Alignment is the symmetry between our values and our actions. It means our inner and outer worlds match.

*Action is when you are conscious that what you say, do and think are in harmony with your values.

Together we build an understanding of what you want to accomplish, and delve deeply into building awareness around any thoughts and assumptions that you may already have. To truly transform your life, I will empower you to rethink what’s possible for you.

__

Learn more about my approach to life consulting and relationship coaching here or get in touch for your free 30-minute consultation here! Don’t forget to follow along @LilyManne on social for more regular updates!