Emotional Hijacking: When You Can’t Speak Your Truth Without Managing Their Emotions

Sometimes you don’t speak up because you’re scared of how they’ll react.
Not because you’re unsure of what you feel.
Not because your request is unreasonable.
But because you already know what happens when you try.

You say, “I wish you’d be more present with my family.”
And suddenly, you’re the villain.
You name something that’s hurt you—and they explode, collapse, cry, shut down, turn it into a story about you—your flaws, your tone, your timing.

That’s the emotional hijack.
And if you’ve been on the receiving end of it for long enough, you start pre-hijacking yourself.
You mute your tone. Soften your words. Time things just right.
You try to say it in a way that won’t set them off.
You manage their regulation before you even get to your truth.

And then something even sadder happens:
You stop saying it.

What Is Emotional Hijacking?

It’s when someone else’s emotional reaction is so big, so fast, or so all-consuming that it eclipses the thing you were trying to say.

You express a need or boundary, and instead of it being met with curiosity, repair, or even disagreement—it gets swallowed whole by their feelings.
Their anger. Their tears. Their defensiveness. Their shutdown.
The spotlight turns. Now the focus is their pain, their confusion, their overwhelm.

You end up tending to them.
Apologizing for your timing.
Smoothing the edges.
Trying to fix the rupture you didn’t cause.

Sometimes the hijack looks like rage.
Sometimes it looks like fragility.
Sometimes it looks like collapsing into silence.

But the effect is the same:
Your truth disappears.
You start protecting their feelings more than you protect your own.

The Cost of Being Hijacked

Over time, you begin to doubt your own perception.
You tell yourself it wasn’t the right time, or you could’ve said it better, or maybe it wasn’t such a big deal after all.

But inside, a quiet frustration grows.
Resentment. Loneliness. A sense that you can never just say what you feel and be met.
Every time you try to speak, the cost feels just a little higher.

And the worst part?
You might look like the “regulated” one. The peacemaker. The emotionally mature partner.
But what’s really happening is emotional overfunctioning.

You’re doing the work of two people.
You’re managing your emotions and theirs.
And it’s exhausting.

Where It Starts

If this pattern feels familiar, it probably didn’t start with your partner.

Maybe growing up, one parent’s feelings took up all the oxygen in the room.
Maybe your anger got met with punishment. Or your sadness made someone else fall apart.

So you learned: protect them first.
Don’t rock the boat.
Don’t be too much.

You became careful.
Skilled at reading a room.
Masterful at soothing others.

But now you’re in a relationship where you still can’t just speak.
And somewhere inside, the question starts to form:

When is it my turn?
When do I get to stop managing and just be heard?

Breaking the Pattern

This kind of dynamic doesn’t shift just by asking the other person to change.
Sometimes, you have to stop rescuing them first.

You stop fixing.
You let the rupture hang in the air.
You allow their discomfort to be theirs.

You say the thing—and you don’t clean it up afterward.
That’s where a new pattern can begin.
Not because they’re different right away, but because you are.

This is called non-contingent novelty—doing something new not to change their reaction, but because the old pattern is costing you too much.

You stop sugarcoating.
You ask for what you need.
You stop managing their responses before they even speak.

And you stop assuming—and finally see what’s real.

For the Emotional Hijacker

Sometimes you’re the one whose emotions take over.

You plan to listen, but the moment your partner brings something up—a complaint, a need, a moment of hurt—it lands like an accusation.
You feel overwhelmed. Hurt. Ashamed. Angry. Criticized.
Maybe they didn’t say it gently. Maybe your feelings surged before you had time to catch them.

But the result is the same: their need disappears.
Their voice gets eclipsed by your reaction.

Terry Real uses a sharp and useful metaphor for this.
It’s like going to a customer service desk.

You walk up and say, “My microwave is broken.”
And the person behind the desk replies, “Oh yeah? Well, my oven’s been broken for months.”

We know how off that is. At a customer service desk, the person who approaches gets to speak.
They name what’s broken.
They ask for help.
And the person behind the desk listens—even if they’re having a hard day, even if their oven really is broken.

That’s the frame for intimacy too.

When your partner comes to you with a hurt, it’s their turn.
They get the spotlight.
Even if it’s hard to hear. Even if you have your own pain.
Your work in that moment is to stay with what they’re bringing—without hijacking it.

You’ll get your turn. But not at the same time.

If you recognize yourself in this, let it be an invitation—not a condemnation.
Because intimacy isn’t about reacting perfectly.
It’s about knowing how to stay steady when it’s not your moment to speak.

And when the volcano starts to rise, try this:
This is the customer service desk. I’m here to listen.
Not because I’m wrong.
Because they were brave enough to go first.

Are you looking for help with your relationship? Do you feel that a relationship coach could help you working on your couples skills? Is communication an issue? Have you ever considered couples therapy or counseling? As a psychotherapist and relationship coach, I am uniquely positioned to help you through these moments of disconnect and conflict.

__

Learn more about my approach to life consulting and relationship coaching here or get in touch for your free 30-minute consultation here! Don’t forget to follow along @LilyManne on social for more regular updates!